Kundli Milan vs Porutham, How North and South India Match Horoscopes

Kundli milan (guna milan or ashtakoot) is the North Indian method of matching two horoscopes on eight kootas, scored out of 36 points, and most astrologers accept 18 or more. Porutham (thirumana porutham) is the Tamil method, which checks ten matches one by one and reads them as passed or failed, with Rajju treated as the one that cannot be missed.
Both start from the same place: the Moon's nakshatra of the bride and the groom. That is why many of their checks overlap, and why they can still disagree.
Free tool: Porutham Calculator. The Tamil 10 porutham for marriage, Rajju and Vedhai included.
Kundli Milan, the 36 Point System
The eight kootas carry rising weights. The smallest is worth 1 point and the largest 8.
| Koota | Points | What it looks at |
|---|---|---|
| Varna | 1 | Temperament grouping of the Moon signs |
| Vashya | 2 | Which partner draws the other |
| Tara | 3 | Count of nakshatras from one to the other |
| Yoni | 4 | Animal symbol of each nakshatra, physical match |
| Graha Maitri | 5 | Friendship between the two Moon sign lords |
| Gana | 6 | Nature, as deva (divine), manushya (human) or rakshasa (fierce) |
| Bhakoot | 7 | Distance between the two Moon signs |
| Nadi | 8 | Aadi (first), madhya (middle) or antya (last) nadi of the nakshatra |
| Total | 36 |
A couple with the same nadi gets 0 of the 8 Nadi points. That is called nadi dosha, and many North Indian astrologers treat it as the most serious single fault, even when the total is above 18. Bhakoot dosha, from certain distances between the Moon signs, is the second one families ask about.
Porutham, the Ten Tamil Checks
A Tamil astrologer goes down this list and marks each one. The result is spoken as "seven out of ten poruthams", along with a note on Rajju.
- Dina porutham is read for health and day-to-day harmony.
- Gana porutham uses the same three-way nature grouping as Gana koota above.
- Mahendra porutham looks at children and the growth of the family.
- Stree Deergha porutham, a count of stars from the bride's to the groom's, read for the wife's welfare.
- Yoni porutham, the animal symbols, as in kundli milan.
- Rasi porutham, the distance between the two Moon signs.
- Rasi Adhipathi porutham, friendship between the sign lords.
- Vasya porutham, mutual attraction.
- Rajju porutham. The 27 stars fall into five rajju groups, named after the head, neck, navel, waist and feet. Both partners in the same rajju is the classic reason to say no.
- Vedha porutham. Certain pairs of stars are said to obstruct each other, and such a pair fails.
Many Tamil families look for at least half the poruthams. Rajju and Vedha must both pass. The exact pass mark varies from one family astrologer to another.
Where the Two Systems Check the Same Thing
Put side by side, six of the ten poruthams have a close cousin in the eight kootas. Gana is Gana. Yoni is Yoni. Rasi porutham does the work of Bhakoot. Rasi Adhipathi does the work of Graha Maitri. Vasya matches Vashya. Dina porutham and Tara koota both count stars from one partner to the other.
The differences sit at the top of each list. Kundli milan's heaviest check is Nadi. Porutham's deciding check is Rajju. Both group the 27 stars, Nadi into three groups and Rajju into five, so they do not pick out the same pairs. Mahendra, Stree Deergha and Vedha have no direct place in kundli milan, and Varna has none in porutham.
Why One Couple Can Pass One and Fail the Other
Because the deciding check is different, a couple can cross 18 points in guna milan and still share the same rajju. A Tamil astrologer would stop there. The reverse happens too: a pair can clear Rajju and Vedha and still have the same nadi, which pulls the guna score down by 8 points at once.
This is common in mixed marriages. A family in Chennai marrying into a family in Indore may get two verdicts on the same pair of horoscopes, and both astrologers are doing their own system correctly.
Which System Do Families in Each Region Use?
| Region | Usual method |
|---|---|
| Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Delhi, Punjab, Gujarat | Kundli milan, 36 points |
| Maharashtra | Mostly kundli milan, called gun milan |
| Tamil Nadu | Ten poruthams |
| Kerala | Ten poruthams, with close attention to chovva dosham (Mars) and papasamyam, a comparison of malefic strength in both charts |
| Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Karnataka | Many astrologers use the 36 point ashtakoota, often with porutham checks too |
These are broad habits, and you will find exceptions in every state.
Neither One Is the Whole Match
Both methods look almost only at the Moon's nakshatra. That is a small slice of two charts. A careful astrologer goes further and reads the 7th house and its lord, Venus, the navamsa chart and the running dasha of both people. Sevvai dosham (manglik) is checked separately in both North and South, because neither guna milan nor porutham covers it.
So if you get 27 out of 36, or eight out of ten poruthams, that is a good start, not a final answer. And a low score is not the end of the conversation either. Families often ask a second astrologer to read the full charts before they decide.
What to Do When the Two Systems Disagree
- Ask each astrologer exactly which check failed. "Nadi dosha" and "Rajju" are clear answers. "Not matching" is not.
- Ask whether a cancellation rule applies. Both traditions have them, for example when the two stars are in the same rasi.
- Have both full charts read together, not only the star match.
- Decide which tradition the two families will follow, and stay with it. Mixing verdicts from two systems leads to confusion.
Before any of this, each partner needs a correct chart. Our Free Birth Chart shows the rasi, nakshatra, navamsa and dosha status in about a minute after a phone OTP check. If you have an old Tamil horoscope, our guide on reading a jathagam shows where the star and rasi are written. For the North Indian side, see the janam kundali terms.
Common Questions
Is 18 Out of 36 Enough for Marriage?
Most astrologers accept 18 or more in kundli milan, provided there is no nadi dosha or bhakoot dosha left uncancelled. Many families prefer a higher score, and nearly all still want the full charts read.
How Many Poruthams Are Needed for Marriage?
There is no single rule. Many Tamil astrologers look for at least five or six of the ten. Rajju and Vedha should both pass.
Is Rajju Porutham the Same as Nadi Dosha?
No. Both group the 27 stars, but Rajju uses five groups and Nadi uses three, so they flag different pairs. Each is the deciding check in its own system.
Can I Use Kundli Milan for a Tamil Marriage?
You can, but the elders on a Tamil side will usually ask for porutham, and especially Rajju. It saves time to have both done.